It is fair to say that many Canadians are unfamiliar with private equity (PE). Yet many Canadians are, effectively, private equity investors. Institutional investors—such as the pension plans that manage Canadians’ pension savings—fund private equity.
The origins of Canada’s PE market date to the 1970s. Influenced to a degree by events taking place in the United States, a local fund management industry emerged in the 1980s. A landmark year was 1983, when Gerry Schwartz founded Onex. The PE fund management industry oversaw a capital pool that Thomson Reuters estimates to be $105.4 billion at the end of 2012. By far, the largest portion of this capital pool ($87.7 billion or 83 per cent of total assets) was managed by 172 Canadian firms active in buyout, mezzanine, and related PE segments of the market.
Understanding Active Management
This report is largely based on structured interviews with 35 senior executives (34 chief executive officers and 1 chief financial officer) of companies that have worked with buy-out equity funds. This method allowed us to understand private equity active management from the perspective of portfolio company executives.
Private equity focuses on two key strategies: first, getting more out of existing capital and, second, realizing opportunities for above-average growth. PE uses two methods. One is concentrated ownership and governance. A second is the pursuit of growth, in both mature and young companies. It is involved in the active management of portfolio companies.
The report is organized around stages of the private equity investment cycle, from the initial rationale for private equity investment to the exiting of the investment.
Why Companies Look to Private Equity
Canada has a large pool of privately held, often family-owned, enterprises. The founder may have worked in the enterprise for many years and built the business through entrepreneurial effort. The owner will have often maintained substantial retained earnings in the company.
The long-term focus of buy-out equity appeals to many of these company owners. For these entrepreneurs, there is an almost visceral fear that a public equity listing will change the fundamental nature of the company. Private equity is more in keeping with the existing governance structure of privately held firms, albeit often replacing family members with professionals.
Selecting the Private Equity Firm
Once owners are convinced of private equity’s financial, governance, and operational virtues, they go through a process of firm selection. A surprising finding is that, in most cases, senior executives who sought out private equity funds were largely unfamiliar with the funds, their investment mandates, and their operational styles. For this reason, managers of portfolio companies often employ brokers and/or advisors to help them with firm selection.
The portfolio company executives we interviewed stressed the need to find the right fit. That means understanding the investing style of the PE firm and its record of accomplishment.
The Investment Phase
The private equity firm’s influence operates through its concentrated ownership stake and through the board to senior managers. In about 30 per cent of our cases, the CEO was not a voting member of the board. In fact, in some cases, there was an “inner board” consisting of the PE owners and an “outer board” that involved other board members.
Respondents universally acknowledged that private equity made two main contributions: strategic focus and finance. Although private equity funds may have some operational expertise—for instance, some general partners (GPs) may have operational backgrounds—GPs tend to be financial and strategic experts. They come into deals with specific financial mandates from their funders (usually institutions and high-net-worth individuals). They then roll these mandates out to the companies in their portfolio.
The portfolio company executives stressed the need to find the right fit. That means understanding the investing style of the PE firm and its record.
Private equity firms generally do not get involved in the day-to-day operation of their portfolio companies. They tend to set the strategic direction, ensure the firm is adequately capitalized, and then allow the senior managers to get on with the achievement of agreed-upon goals.
Exiting the Investment
All PE firms go into portfolio companies with an exit strategy. This strategy may involve a period of time (e.g., within five years) and/or performance criteria (e.g., improvement in enterprise value). The actual timing of the exit depends on something beyond the control of the PE firm and the portfolio company—the exit market. In over half of our cases, the PE firm had yet to exit the position. This was partly explained by a soft exit market—a lingering effect of the credit crisis. Those that had exited were much more likely to have done so through strategic acquisitions or through sales to another PE firm than through an initial public offering.
The Final Analysis
In our sample, private equity scored extremely highly by those individuals who were best placed to evaluate it. They scored PE well over 4 out of 5 in terms of both performance and their willingness to recommend it to others. A subsample of our population realized over 100 per cent growth in earnings and 73 per cent growth in sales over the investment period.
We highlight three specific cases to illustrate the intricate workings of private equity investments. The cases are Calgary’s MEG Energy Corp.; Bluewave Energy Inc. of Dartmouth, Nova Scotia; and Knowlton Development Corporation of Knowlton, Quebec. These cases clearly show that private equity plays a critical role in helping companies to increase scale and to link into global value chains.
The report concludes with key lessons for prospective portfolio companies (in terms of linking up with private equity), private equity financiers, and government policy-makers.