Established businesses have legacy management systems, whereas start-ups design their management from scratch. Established businesses may survive for a period without innovation, but competitive pressures may suddenly force them to innovate. Moreover, established businesses are more likely to be large—and large businesses come with complex management structures and processes involving many people and, often, varied geographies.
In this report, we focus on the specific challenges facing established businesses that wish to innovate to improve their competitive position. (A later report will look at the specific innovation challenges facing start-up businesses.) We distill key innovation management principles for these businesses and illustrate the principles, using findings from interviews with 16 leading innovative companies.
What Is Innovation Management?
Innovation management is the set of formal and informal mechanisms companies use to execute new business strategies, with the goal of improving a firm’s competitive position through fundamental change.
A company’s strategy determines innovation. Strategy is conceived by senior leadership and approved by the board of directors. Leaders play the key role in setting strategic direction. Leadership needs to persuade shareholders, boards of directors, and employees that innovation is a sound business strategy that will address their (often disparate) needs. As the OECD says, “… management and an appropriate strategic outlook are key factors. They determine much of the scope for the external linkages and the positive attitudes inside firms that promote receptivity to the adoption of improved practices and improved technology.”1
The Leadership Imperative
Established businesses typically require strong leadership to innovate. Innovation is difficult. Dodgson, Gann, and Phillips point out that the risks, costs, and time horizons of innovation may conflict with the financial objectives, operational routines, and managerial incentives
of businesses.2 Innovation is risky.
The short-term pain of innovation is very real for established businesses. Data from the Centre for Business Innovation (CBI) survey show that most innovation challenges boil down to either leadership or the managerial competency of leadership.
In a 2012 Boston Consulting Group survey, the most-cited source of innovation was the CEO. The survey also showed that companies need to take a holistic approach to innovation, which needs to be directed by senior management. This survey broadly agreed with a 2007 study of the retail banking sector,3 which found that CEO attention and innovation outcomes are linked. CEOs who are focused on the future are faster at adopting new technologies and developing new products based on new technologies.
Cisco Canada provides a good example of innovation leadership in practice. Cisco Canada’s approach to innovation is driven by Nitin Kawale, President of Cisco’s Canadian unit.4 Through his and his leadership team’s drive, the Canadian market is now one of Cisco’s top four worldwide markets, which is a major achievement, given the relatively small size of Canada’s market.
Building Innovation Into the Business
Innovation is a means to achieve strategic objectives. Leaders communicate the need for innovation by setting business strategy. When they do so, they signal to key stakeholders (boards of directors, shareholders, employees, and others) that the business intends to innovate to achieve strategic goals. The company then uses a performance metric system to measure progress on innovation. All these elements set the business up for a series of other managerial decisions—everything from selecting people to funding innovation projects—as these decisions flow from the strategy.
Depending on the strategy, innovation can take the form of a product or service, process, marketing, or organizational innovation. Effective innovation strategy: is based on an in-depth, factual analysis of the current market position, desired state, and gaps;
- prescribes specific medium- and long-term areas of focus;
- establishes bold, clearly defined objectives and metrics to focus the organization’s attention;
- allocates significant resources—people, money, and equipment—to find solutions to close the gap between the current state and desired state;
- has a clearly defined process to find solutions to achieve the breakthrough strategy. (This process involves asking such questions as “What are the right questions to ask that will
- generate new ideas?” “Who are a company’s sources of ideas?” and “How does a company quickly turn ideas into solutions?”)
Managing the Innovation Process
Innovation starts with a process of asking the right questions to the right people in such a way that they generate new ideas. The company winnows these new ideas down to a few priorities that could significantly change the firm’s products or services, processes, organization, or marketing. It then puts these critical few into a process to take them from idea to implemented solution. A business can have great leadership, strategy, structures, and metrics, but if it does not have a process for implementing great ideas, it will not be a successful innovator.
In one way, innovation is open-ended and creative. It is about asking the right questions and visualizing new things and processes. However, it is also close-ended and disciplined. It is about focusing on the best ideas that show the greatest promise of commercial success. That success depends on disciplined execution.5
Key Takeaways
Established businesses that wish to innovate need to understand the following principles:
- Bold leadership is at the heart of innovative companies.
- Strategy determines where and how companies innovate.
- Structure organizes the innovation effort.
- Successful innovative companies give innovation efforts adequate resources and stay the course.
- Innovation process management is important.
- It’s people who innovate, so people management is critical to innovation success.