Printer icon Print Page

Executive Summary

Bridging the Valley: Linking Public Investments in Research to Business Innovation

by Michael Grant

Today, federal and provincial governments spend around $4.5 billion each year in support of research at Canada’s universities alone.1 The share of Canada’s total research expenditures attributed to higher education (primarily university) institutions has increased from less than 30 per cent in 2000 to around 40 per cent today.

Given the growing levels of university research funding, Canada’s ongoing poor productivity and innovation performance is perplexing. Clearly something more than money is required if Canada is to benefit from its financial commitment to university research.

Strategies for Building the Bridge

Building the bridge between university research and business innovation may involve encouraging academics to:

  • commercialize ideas directly;
  • collaborate with businesses to commercialize ideas;
  • train and support highly qualified people to commercialize ideas.

In terms of commercializing directly, Canada’s performance is weak. In 2012, Canadian universities’ intellectual property (IP) revenue from all sources (including royalties, milestone payments, and sales of IP) amounted to only $70 million.2 By comparison, in the same year, U.S. universities generated over US$2.6 billion from licensing.3

University patents are often developed in isolation from the practical solutions being developed by business. In fact, a university and a company may be working on a solution to a technical problem in parallel. The company is not interested in licensing technology that duplicates its efforts or that is otherwise not integrated into its ideal customer solution. Unless university researchers are directly collaborating with business, there is much less likelihood that their research will support commercial innovation.

That explains why university contract research revenue is about 10 times as great as patent revenue. Large companies, in particular, are well positioned to simply purchase research services from the university. This is actually highly collaborative and effective, but appears to be used mostly by large and often foreign-based companies.

In terms of training highly qualified people, less than one-fifth of employed doctoral degree holders are full-time university professors, even though that is the main career interest of those who pursue a PhD. The vast majority of PhD holders are working elsewhere in the economy; many are not generating earnings anywhere near their human capital potential. For instance, a 2013 survey of Canadian postdoctoral fellows found that two-thirds of respondents earned less than $45,000 per annum.4

The Way Forward

The study makes a number of practical recommendations to improve the links between university research and business innovation. These include:

Change Professor Incentives

Professorial career advancement should place more value on industry collaboration. Currently, career advancement is based first on publication, second on teaching, and third on community engagement. But collaboration with industry is much more difficult than presenting research findings at a community seminar. Those professors who choose industry engagement should not be penalized for making this choice.

Change Funding Models to Encourage Collaboration

One option for public funders is to use their financial wherewithal to encourage collaboration—along the lines of the Automotive Partnership Canada program. This would involve redistributing existing funding toward collaboration programs.

Another option is to put purchasing power in the hands of companies or industry clusters to bid for professors’ time on research projects that industry believes have merit. The Ontario Centres of Excellence has taken steps toward such a system through its Collaboration Voucher Program.5

But if new collaboration funding expands the demand for collaborations, we may need new players to get involved as the universities may be stretched. The German Fraunhofer-Gesellschaft model is one approach—intermediary research institutions focused on applied industry innovation.

Make Universities a Part of Innovation Ecosystems

If Canada is to build innovation ecosystems, universities need to specialize in areas where the local economy has the capacity to absorb and apply knowledge. In many cases, university research is largely divorced from the surrounding economy. This suggests a need for greater focus in university research specialization and funding. Canada does not have the resources to compete effectively across all areas of academic endeavour to obtain economic benefits. Funders need to incent universities to specialize in areas where Canada can be a world leader and where local businesses can be positioned to grow and take on the world.

1    Canadian Association of University Business Officers, Financial Information. Tracking actual research spending is an inexact science because of different accounting concepts and time periods used in the data series. For instance, the Association reports that the National Sciences and Engineering Research Council (NSE RC) was the source for $790 million in spending in 2013–14 whereas the Council itself says its total budget is $1.1 billion. See NSE RC, A World of Discovery.

2    Association of University Technology Managers, AUTM Canadian Licensing.

3    Association of University Technology Managers, AUTM U.S. Licensing. Note that even at US$2.6 billion, the licensing revenue of U.S. universities pales in comparison to their contract revenues.

4    See Canadian Association of Postdoctoral Scholars and Mitacs, The 2013 Post-Doc Survey, iii.

5    See Ontario Centres of Excellence, Collaboration Voucher Program.

Photo of Michael Grant Michael Grant
Research Director
Industry and Business Strategy

Read the Full Report

Image of Bridging the Valley: Linking Public Investments in Research to
Business Innovation report coverCanada is a world leader in public investments in R&D, but lags in innovation performance. This report examines why Canada is falling behind other OECD countries.

CBI Mailing List

Join CBI’s mailing list. You will be notified about CBI’s latest research reports and activities.

Contact CBI

For more information on the Centre for Business Innovation, send us an email.